DOUBT – Written by John Patrick Shanley; Directed by M. Shane Grant. Produced by Coal Creek Theatre Company of Louisville (presented at the Louisville Center for the Arts, 801 Grant, Louisville) through November 14. Tickets available at CCTLouisville.org.
The artistry of Shanley in this script is in his ability to draw two characters at such dramatic odds against each other without making one or the other a clear-cut villain. DOUBT creates a situation during which your belief vacillates from scene to scene. A nun’s immediate suspicion of a new parish priest seems unfounded and exaggerated. The priest’s defense of his actions seems heartfelt and innocent, yet somehow devious. In a knockdown scene between the two, there are still no clear answers, with even the final scene remaining rich with ambiguities.
Regardless, under the sure-handed direction of Shane Grant, the current production in Louisville gives Shanley’s script a thorough scrub. Key to the drama is the determined Sister Aloysius, given a strong performance by Jessica Shepard. While the audience may be confused by her actions, there is no hesitation on her part. “I saw that little thing. You did! No matter what you say, I know you for a bad person.” No ifs, ands, or buts! Her strength is monumental and comes from somewhere inside Jessica’s personality to inhabit Sister A.
It’s hard to believe that the Robert Janacek portraying the dubious Father Flynn is the same man I saw having so much fun in a recent raucous production of THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG. He embraces the dichotomy of Father Flynn with a performance that plays either guilty or innocent, depending on which scene is on deck. He can be surprised, stunned, disbelieving, angry, hurt, cajoling, and defensive – all within the span of a few minutes. The Catholics in the audience find themselves rethinking their past relationships with the priests in their lives. Was he questioning himself in his first fervent sermon or practicing subterfuge?
The apex of the situation is a 12-year-old African American student – the first at St. Nicholas, moved there by his concerned mother. She is desperate to get him through elementary school, away from the bullies . . . and his father. Mrs. Muller, as played by Lisa Ann Collins, is grounded in the realities of her son’s life and trying to find a safe place for him to land. While we never directly meet her son, Donald, the audience is left with a clear picture of his life and sympathizes with her efforts to protect, love, and accept the dilemma of her life.
Each character plays their part with grace and understanding of the story. The fourth actor is Sister James (Rachel Hughes), a young teacher torn asunder by her part in the drama, fluctuating between the two people who are supposed to be supporting her as a teacher and as a religious. Her journey echoes the one taken by the audience as we are all left with DOUBT.
A lovely tranquil pulpit, office and garden are provided by the scenic designer Jaccie Serbus. The peaceful environment is assisted by subtle lighting and sound enhancements that belie the heartfelt drama being enacted. The juxtaposition of the nun’s dignified black habits is contrasted against the priest’s – dare I say? – flashy, beautiful church robes.
Overheard exit conversations reinforced my belief that the audience was as uncertain as I about where the truth lies in this situation. I invite you to visit Coal Creek Theatre – one of my favorite small groups of dedicated storytellers – to make up your own mind.
A WOW factor of 8.75!!